31 Comments

"there don't seem to be any adults behind the wheel." Oh they're 21+ all right, but they're dispositionally inclined inclined to want to witness a big boom. As someone who worked for a few years as a science writer for two of the three nuclear weapons (NNSA) national labs, my conversations with nuclear physicists and engineers led me to the conclusion that their supercomputer modeling efforts in behalf of "stockpile stewardship" left them frustrated. Why? Because they were banned from actual testing of their adorable weapons, leaving some doubts that they'd perform to their intended homicidal level. At this and other levels of the nuclear weapons establishment, the sociopaths exert enormous pressure to sustain this madness of refurbishing plutonium triggers and other dastardly pursuits. This represents yet another huge danger to having an unelected "deep state" driving policy decisions in this arena of ongoing madness. Don't ever be deluded into thinking that sane folks are driving this policy. You don't demur from the standard nukes-are-wonderful-deterrents propaganda if you like your quite well-paying gig in that jungle.

Expand full comment
Jan 22, 2022·edited Jan 22, 2022

If the placement of troops is what determines a nation's threat level, then the world should be terrified by the United States indeed. Again, why is detente missing from our current conversations?

Expand full comment

As a former cold war analyst I was deeply disturbed by how uninformed politically appointed leaders overseeing the intelligence community were. An interested amateur knew more about the world. Their militarism makes them into nincompoops.

Expand full comment

I agree with a commenter of Moon of Alabama on this. The US would be satisfied to be able to say that Russia backed down on invading Ukraine. As another of its commenters said, people still believe that the US had the upper hand in the Cuban missile crisis, even though the USSR had what it really wanted, that is, the dismantling of missiles in Turkey and a promise not to invade Cuba.

Selling arms and whatever to Ukraine is a nice bonus and requesting more material from the military industrial complex under the pretext of a forthcoming war is the ultimate goal

Expand full comment

Thank you

-- the SAME fat bastard who played key role in Russia-gate hoax

-- concocted by the SAME lying team

-- Obama-Biden-Hillary-Pelosi-Schumer-Schiff and the rest of DNC-CIA /FBI Co.

They will for sure try to prevent 2022 elections - as "illegal" - in order to stay in power.

Expand full comment

"McFaul later claimed that Biden was too focused on opposing China during his first year in office, causing the Russia situation to get out of control."

Gee, whatever happened with the post election prediction that Republicans would accuse Biden of being "controlled by China" just as Democrats accuse Trump of being in bed with the Russians? Caitlin is spot on in this article. Absent a provocation, Putin will be content to allow the Kiev regime to stew in its own juices until it collapses entirely. He may then help Novorossiya (coastal and eastern Ukraine) rebuild.

Putin has no interest in occupying the strongholds of neo-Nazism in western Ukraine, so he will ignore minor provocations and has no need to launch a false-flag provocation as some foreign policy pundits have predicted. Should Kiev invade the Donbass, the invading army will be trapped as in the Debaltsevo cauldron by Novorossiyan forces, then destroyed by long range Russian rocket and artillery. No need to invade.

A much greater threat to world peace is the NATO missile installations in Romania and Poland. These are ostensibly defensive installations to intercept Iranian ballistic missiles. However, they are capable of launching nuclear armed cruise missiles, so they are indeed an existential threat to Russia while Ukraine is not.

Expand full comment

Also, Alexander Vindman is from Ukraine! We can't let a partisan to that conflict dictate to our perceptions whether or not war with a nuclear power is inevitable.

Expand full comment

Si l'enfer c'est installé dans nos vies (Covid), ils n'y manque que les flames !!

Expand full comment

It's a very useful distraction, by governments seeking to escape the consequences of their "public health" policies, and a reason to increase surveillance and censorship. Using the Soviet term, it's "maskirovska" - the enemy being the population ruled by these governments...

Expand full comment

There is another hidden dimension: Russia is not just negotiating items with the US, but also Israel is heavily involved in this calculus too:

https://www.timesofisrael.com/mks-demand-netanyahu-answer-questions-about-spurned-russia-syria-deal/

Expand full comment

Having to participate in the practice and planning of nuclear war was depressing to say the least. I remember at the end of a brief, the general asks about enemy moral. I told him they feel as any rational person, that there be a peaceful diplomatic solution.

Expand full comment

BDS everyone and everything zionist every day, in every way you can. it's your human duty, and your responsibility for your own children and grandchildren.

Expand full comment

I think it would be reasonable to mention that since retiring from the NSC, Vindman was awarded a staff position with Lawfare by way of a fellowship funded by the Pritzker Military Foundation, the "philanthropic" organization chaired by billionaire Jennifer Pritzker, whose family of billionaires has a long history of industrial production for the US military.

Expand full comment

Finally subscribed to your Sub, Caity. Don't ask me why it took so long. As always, great analysis on the REALLY dangerous virus that is infecting our humanity.

Expand full comment

Hmm, at the moment the staging areas are a little too far from the border, most tanks and fighting vehicles are parked, and there are none of them strapped on top of flatbed transporters. Additionally, there is no attempt at camouflaging said staging areas, and no discernable siting and works for artillery, whether for practice (180 degrees from direction of advance) or in preparation for an invasion.

Expand full comment

I am almost certain in my mind, yes pretty well sure that these paid blatherskites are very silly.

Expand full comment